CVL vs Compulsory or Court Liquidation (CL)
A Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation and a Court Liquidation both wind up an insolvent company. The difference is who starts it. In a CVL, the directors act and choose the liquidator. In a Court Liquidation, a creditor applies to the court and the timing is out of the directors’ hands.
Read on to learn more
CVL vs Compulsory or Court Liquidation (CL)
A CVL and a Compulsory or Court Liquidation (CL) both involve an insolvent company being wound up because it cannot pay its debts. The main difference is that how the liquidation begins. A CVL is initiated by the company, whereas a CL follows a court order, often after a creditor has taken legal action.
What is a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL)?
A CVL is a voluntary process used when directors recognise that a company is insolvent and cannot continue to pay its debts. The directors may resolve that the company should be wound up, followed by a resolution of shareholders to appoint a registered liquidator.
Once appointed, the liquidator takes control of the company’s affairs, investigates its financial position, realises available assets and distributes funds to creditors in accordance with the statutory requirements.
A CVL does not require a court order.
What is a Court Liquidation (CL)?
A CL occurs when a court makes an order to wind up the company, usually following an application by a creditor, “the petitioning creditor”. A creditor will apply to the court for a winding up order after the company has failed to pay a debt.
The court then considers the application and, if it makes a winding up order, the liquidation proceeds under the supervision of the court. A registered liquidator is appointed to administer the company’s affairs, investigate its financial position and deal with its assets and creditor claims.
Unlike a CVL, the directors do not choose to commence the liquidation. The process is generally initiated because a creditor or another eligible party has applied to the court.
Differences at a glance:
| Comparison | CVL | CL |
|---|---|---|
| How it starts | Directors and shareholders initiate the process | Court makes a winding up order |
| Court involvement | Not required | Application and order are required |
| Who initiates | Company directors | Often a creditor |
| Liquidator | Appointed through the voluntary process | Appointed following the court’s order |
| Trigger | Directors recognise the insolvency | Company fails to pay a debt and a winding up application is made |
| Costs paid by | Usually the directors. Can be shareholders or any other interested party. | The petitioning creditor at first. Recoverable in the liquidation as a priority. |
| Control of company affairs | Passes to the liquidator | Passes to the liquidator |
Which process is appropriate?
The appropriate course depends on the company’s circumstances. Directors should obtain professional advice before deciding how to proceed.
A CVL is preferrable if you want to control the timing and choose who is appointed as liquidator.
A director might wait to see if a creditor initiates a CL if they can’t afford to pay liquidation fees.
Regardless of how the liquidation starts, the liquidator investigates the company’s affairs and works to identify and realise assets for the benefit of creditors. This may include reviewing the company’s books and records, investigating transactions prior liquidation and considering whether any money or assets can be recovered. The liquidator also deals with creditor claims and distributes available funs to the applicable priority rules.
The Importance of Seeking Professional Advice
This article has aimed to provide general information about the difference between CVL and Compulsory or Court Liquidation, however, every company’s exact circumstances are different. We strongly encourage directors of an insolvent company, or those facing a statutory demand or winding up application to give an insolvency professional like Dissolve a call to discuss your specific circumstances. Dissolve may even recommend cheaper (or free!) solutions than other insolvency firms.
Other Liquidation Information
Contact Us
Please either give us a call or submit the form and we will get back to you.
